7 Ingredients to Avoid In Toothpaste

7 Ingredients to Avoid In Toothpaste

“You will brush your teeth 1,000 times per year or more, and each time you do, you will ingest some toothpaste. If you think that is not a problem, think again.  Some of the ingredients in many commercial types of toothpaste are undeniably bad for you."  Dr. Harold Katz, DDS, Founder of the California Breath Clinics.

Let’s face it, toothpaste is BIG business.  I mean, have you looked at the dental aisle in the markets?  With one paste claiming great for sensitivity, one for whitening, one for remineralizing teeth, and even ones that do a quick all in one, it’s honestly baffling and mind-blowing to try and choose what one is best…..I know I feel that way, and I’m a hygienist!!

This is a big topic for me.  Personally, I feel the least amount of ingredients in toothpaste the better, I find that rarely do toothpaste “deal” with the problem; instead, they mask the issue at best.  Here is a list of the most frequent dangers of traditional toothpaste.

Ingredients in Toothpaste to Avoid

Sodium Lauryl Sulfate (most toothpaste on the market)

Sodium lauryl sulfate is a surfactant, detergent and emulsifier used in thousands of cosmetic products, as well as in industrial cleaners. A study appearing in Exogenous Dermatology confirmed SLS to be a very "corrosive irritant" to the skin—irritation which persisted in research subjects for 3 weeks.SLS damages the tissues by stripping the skin of its protective oils and moisture.  SLS dries the tissue, and is thought to cause canker sores, and in lab rats, the ingredient led to depression, diarrhea and death.  The U.S. National Institutes of Health recommends using other ingredients in toothpaste because of the side effects of sodium lauryl sulfate.

Fluoride

Fluoride is a naturally occurring element found in the earth. It is found in small amounts in the air, water and in some plants. Just because it is a naturally occurring component of the environment does not mean it is good for humans to ingest. A study by B.K. Drummond and M.E.J. Curzon, published in the 1985 issue of the "Journal of Dental Research," on the ingestion of toothpastes by children, found that the fluoride was absorbed into the body through the mouth from brushing with fluoride toothpastes. The conclusion was that parents should closely monitor the use of fluoride toothpaste in their children. The EPA considers fluoride a toxin.Exposure to high levels (30 times the amount found in fluoridated water) of fluoride can cause skeletal fluorosis causing joint pain, limited range of joint movement and more brittle bones with a higher rate of fracture. Much of the concern over fluoride in toothpaste arises from the combination of higher amounts of fluoride in water, fluoride products used to protect tooth enamel and naturally occurring fluorides in plants for an overall increase of total ingested fluoride.  If you must use fluoride toothpaste, consider one with sodium fluoride, and one that avoids the use of SLS.  An example of this type of toothpaste is Squigle, Enamel Saver Tooth Paste.

Stannous Fluoride (Crest Pro Health)

Stannous fluoride found in pastes can stain teeth, affect your taste buds, cause gum reactions and may interfere with permanent repair (remineralization) of the tooth.

Triclosan (Colgate Total)

Triclosan is an anti-microbial and antifungal agent listed as a pesticide and is used in everything ranging from antibacterial soaps, deodorants, acne medications, and Colgate Total tooth paste. The Environmental Protection Agency demanded more research be conducted because of Triclosan’s negative effects on thyroid and estrogen levels. Troubling results from animal studies showed that it could reduce levels of thyroid hormones, which play a key role in regulating metabolism. Other recent studies suggest that long-term use of products containing Triclosan can increase bacteria's resistance to antibiotics.

Sorbitol

Sorbitol is used as a preservative and a sweetener in toothpaste. It is a non-nutritive sweetener that can have a laxative effect. Sorbitol draws water into the large intestine and stimulates bowel movements, and is thought to be partially responsible for acid reflux.

Tartar Control Toothpastes

Many tartar control toothpastes are acidic, which often leads to increased sensitivity. They may dissolve some of the buildup, but the acidity pulls calcium from the teeth which can actually form more buildup. The acidity also encourages more plaque to grow.

FD&C blue dye No. 2

FD&C blue dye No. 2  is in many toothpastes, but the Center for Science in the Public Interest warns against it as it might be related to learning and behavioral issues, severe allergic reactions and other health problems. 

Now it seems as if it is doom and gloom for poor old toothpaste, but fear not, there are quite a few brands that go out of their way to create toothpastes that are effective and healthy.  What nutritionists recommend you stick to with food should apply to oral care products as well.Look for toothpaste with natural ingredients like essential oils.

The Tooth and Gums line has a great antiseptic toothpaste, Vita-Myr has a line of toothpaste that are herbal and contain things like xylitol and CoQ10 for both children and adults. Squiggle's Tooth Builder is a fluoride-free toothpaste that was developed for people who develop mouth sores due to radiation treatment or get canker sores.  Tooth Builder stops most canker sores and mouth ulcers, and has the highest concentration of xylitol.  Best of all the fluoride-free formula can be left in the mouth instead of rinsing it away.

Xylitol is an excellent cavity-fighting sweetener used by companies like Vita-Myr, Branam and Squigle.  Weleda oral care products are good alternatives as well. If you want to avoid toothpaste altogether, then consider Xylitol Tooth Powder by Ice Chips candy.  This amazing product contains xylitol, Himalayan salt, baking soda, sage, and essential oils that whiten the teeth and freshen the breath.  A great product with amazing cleaning power!

Tell us below in the comments:  What toothpaste do you use?


Want to take control of your oral health?

Check out our free guides for pH control products and controlling kids' cavities. These comprehensive guides provide tips and tricks to help you achieve better oral health. 

And if you're ready to take your oral health to the next level, be sure to sign up for our course. Our oral health coaching program is designed to help you achieve optimal oral health.

Visit www.oralhealthcoaching.com to learn more and sign up today.

Carrie Ibbetson RDH

I am a dental hygienist, oral health coach and creator of Oral Health Coaching, an online course that teaches you how to care for your mouth with life long results. I help families all over the world and work locally in person as a personal trainer for your mouth. Please get in touch to see how we can work together.

Previous
Previous

Mouth Mate: A Game-Changer in Oral Care Maintenance

Next
Next

Navigating Your Health Today with Emergency Nurse Antonie Mulder